Most owners have hired the great interview who turned into a bad week on the job. The working interview is the fix. It is also the step most often done wrong: unpaid, unplanned, or set on a job where one mistake costs you a customer.
What a working interview is
It is the last step before an offer, after the phone screen and the sit-down interview. The candidate works a set stretch, often a half day, on real but contained work next to one of your people. You pay them for the time. At the end you decide, and you tell them either way.
It is not a free trial, a probation period or a way to get a job done cheap. If a candidate leaves feeling used, word gets around your trade fast.
Pay them, every time
If someone does productive work for your business, federal wage law generally treats them as your employee for that time. That means at least minimum wage for every hour, per the U.S. Department of Labor's Fair Labor Standards Act guidance. Many states and cities set a higher minimum than the federal one. The simple rule: pay the rate of the job you are hiring for.
A one-day hire is still a hire on paper. Ask your accountant or payroll provider how they want it run, and call your insurance agent to confirm your workers' comp covers someone working a trial day. This is not legal advice, and the rules change by state. A ten-minute call to each is worth it before the first trial.
Set it up before the day
Send the candidate the plan in writing, by text or email, a day or two ahead:
- When and where. The date, the start time, the address and who to ask for.
- How long. A half day is enough for most seats. A full day can make sense for a senior seat.
- What to bring. Their own hand tools, boots and any license or certification card the seat needs.
- The pay. The rate, and when and how they get paid.
- The work. One line on what the day looks like.
Then pick the work. It should be real, so you see real skill, and contained, so one mistake does not land on a customer. Think prep and cleanup on a repaint, a service call with your lead tech, roughing in a circuit in a garage or a maintenance visit. Keep licensed work inside the license they hold, under the eye of someone licensed. Hand them the same safety gear and rules your crew follows.
Tell your lead what you want watched. The person working next to the candidate sees more in four hours than you will in a week of interviews.
What to watch
- The start. On time, dressed for the work, tools in hand.
- The questions. Good people ask before they guess. Watch for the one who never asks and then redoes the work.
- The prep and the cleanup. In a home service trade this is half the job, and it is the part customers remember.
- The customer's home. Drop cloths, shoe covers, where they set their tools, how they talk when the homeowner walks in.
- Taking direction. Your lead asks them to do it a different way. Do they adjust or argue?
- Safety. Ladders, power off before the cover comes off, eye protection. No shortcuts to look fast.
- The crew. At lunch, does the crew talk to them or around them?
Score the day the same way for everyone
Before the first trial, write down five things you will rate from 1 to 5: skill on the task, care with the home, safety, taking direction and fit with the crew. Your lead fills it in the same day, before the details fade. The same five for every candidate means you compare people, not moods. A 4 or 5 across the board is an offer. A 1 on safety is a no, however good the rest looked.
Decide fast, and close it out either way
Make the call within a day or two. Good candidates rarely sit on one option, and the shop that decides first often gets the hire. Pay for the trial day on time, whatever you decide. If it is a no, a short, kind message is enough: thank them for the day and wish them well. If it is a yes, call them. Do not text an offer.
Where the working interview fits
It is the last filter, not the first. A trial day for every applicant burns your lead's week. The order that works for trade shops:
- A job post that says the pay and the work.
- A screen of every applicant against one scorecard.
- A ten-minute phone screen. Here are the phone screen questions I use.
- A sit-down interview with trade questions, like these for electricians and for HVAC techs.
- The paid working interview.
- The offer.
To be fair
A working interview costs you something. You pay for the day, and your lead gives up half a day of output to watch. Some strong candidates are still working another job and cannot take a weekday off, so offer a Saturday or a shorter block. And half a day only shows you half a day: someone nervous can look slow, and someone on their best behavior can hide a habit. Use it with the scorecard and the references, not instead of them.
My take
For a small shop, a paid working interview is one of the cheapest ways to avoid a bad hire. Pay for it, plan it, have your lead score it and decide fast. If you would rather not spend your evenings on the steps before it, our recruiting lane handles them. We write the post, screen every applicant on your scorecard, phone screen the strong ones and hand you only the cleared candidates. You run the interview and the trial day, and you make the call.