Why ten minutes on the phone first
A resume tells you what someone wrote down. Ten minutes on the phone tells you whether they call back and whether they can explain their own work. It also shows whether the basics line up: the hours, the drive, the pay and the start date. Most mismatches show up in the first two minutes. It is better to find them on a short call than an hour into an interview.
Before you dial
- Write the scorecard first. What the seat needs: license or certification, years doing the work, the kind of work, the schedule and the pay range. Every question below checks one line of it.
- Ask the same five, every time. Use the same questions in the same order, so you compare people instead of conversations.
- Call, then text. If they do not pick up, send a short text with your name, your shop and the job, and ask for a good time for a ten-minute call. Plenty of good tradespeople cannot answer on a job site.
The opener can be this simple: "This is [your name] with [your shop], calling about the [job title] job. Is now still a good time? It is about ten minutes, five quick questions."
The five questions
1. The basics
"The job is [full time, days, the area you cover]. Does that schedule work, how long would your drive be, and when could you start?" Add the must-haves for the seat: a valid driver's license if they drive a company truck, the license or certification the work requires, and any check your shop runs before hiring.
Listen for: a plain yes to each. Red flag: a no on a must-have. That ends the call, kindly. There is no point in the next eight minutes.
2. Pay and why now
"What pay are you looking for, and what has you looking right now?"
Listen for: a number inside your range and a clear reason, such as more hours, a shorter drive, a shop that will teach them or a bad fit where they are. Red flag: a number far above your range with no give, or "just something for now" for a seat you want filled for years.
Ask what they want, not what they made. A growing number of states and cities ban asking about pay history.
3. The work they do today
"Walk me through a normal day at your current or last job. What kind of jobs, what do you do yourself, and what do you hand off?"
Listen for: specifics, such as tasks, tools, the kinds of homes or systems, and who they worked with. Red flag: only general words, or a story that does not match the resume.
4. A real story
"Tell me about the last job that went wrong. What happened, and what did you do about it?"
Listen for: a real job, their own part in it, and what they changed after. Red flag: nothing ever went wrong, or everything was someone else's fault.
5. One trade check
One question a working tradesperson answers in a sentence and a pretender cannot. A few examples:
- Electrician: "What is the difference between a GFCI and an AFCI, and where would you use each?"
- HVAC tech: "Which EPA Section 608 certification do you hold?"
- Painter: "How do you prep a peeling exterior window frame before you paint it?"
- Plumber: "A customer has no hot water. What do you check first on a gas water heater?"
Listen for: a quick, specific answer. You are not grading the whole trade on the phone, only checking that they have done the work. Save the deep questions for the interview: electrician interview questions and HVAC interview questions.
Score it the same way, every time
Right after the call, rate each answer from 1 to 5 and write one line of notes. Decide the rule before the first call. Mine: a 4 or 5 overall, with no red flag on question one, moves forward the same day. Everyone else gets a short, polite no. A same-day yes matters, because the strong ones are usually talking to more than one shop.
What never to ask
Keep the call to the job. Federal law makes it illegal to base hiring decisions on race, color, religion, sex (including pregnancy), national origin, age (40 or older), disability or genetic information, per the EEOC. Questions that touch those areas can be read as evidence that you did. So skip these:
- Age or graduation year.
- Marriage, kids, childcare or plans for a family. The EEOC calls these questions out by name.
- Religion, church or which days they observe.
- Where they or their family are from. You may ask whether they are legally allowed to work in the US.
- Health, injuries, disability or medications. You may ask whether they can do the essential tasks of the job, with or without an accommodation.
- Past pay, wherever your state or city bans the question.
If a candidate brings one of these up on their own, say "Understood," move on, and do not write it down. This is a short list, not legal advice. State and local rules add more, so check yours.
Close the call
"That is everything, thank you. If it is a fit, you will hear from us in a day or two about next steps." Never promise the job on a phone screen, and never offer an interview before you have scored the call.
To be fair
A script can make a call feel like a form. Use the five as a spine and let people talk. Some great tradespeople are terrible on the phone, and some smooth talkers are mediocre on a job. That is why the phone screen only decides who gets an interview, never who gets hired. The paid working interview is where you see the work.
My take
Ten minutes, five questions, one score and a same-day decision: that habit alone puts a small shop ahead of the bigger ones that take a week to call back. If the pile is too big to call yourself, our recruiting lane runs this step for you. We screen every applicant on your scorecard and phone screen the strong ones. Only the cleared candidates reach you, with one written page each.